[Sundaycommunity] Fwd: A politics of hope and healthy populism that is necessary
Arthur Blomme
art at integralshift.ca
Thu Oct 3 16:46:21 PDT 2024
Thanks Pat
The first article in the news letter you sent is a very good article.
In the article /*The Possibilities and Perils of Populism
<https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVT63qgyTW8wLKSR6lZ3p0W62NmVS2ByjgFW3j9Mx120Dz6QW2_95602ZBV5pW5wPlM929lsBwN8_xf6L6RWmlW1J72fV3FrSKgW7GF9Rc11GPJQW1Fj1z831qk_LW5s0xD71zf5f5W89MRqK4_zFlQW6BfLBK1Kk1WsW4mcdqk2_5s4BW25KpMX7mxdbrN96nHGChw8s-W3XpJhd55sbHxW7M9Vvy1PCqxVW7bR7Q_3hLRKmW5SC5wk1tH-xyW2_GKTh2sXP6_W55CZsY9lc4FnW13Qw3z8rfxmyN2KL59XZQWY3W4TJLVh23KgNwW7-z-yw4XLMDsW72lrlN3XVMFlW7v465C89vH4kW7WSb-W1ylp7QW33h7NJ37QKVZf8ln6Hj04>*_:A
working-class perspective on the fragile American dream _/Skyler Adleta
concludes:
> There is a kind of populism that can be healthy—more than that, might
> be/necessary/—for our country to heal. But it must be a populism
> dedicated to mutual respect, not one guided by vengeance and stagnant
> grievance. Having the ability to advocate for and see one another
> clearly is the only thing that will begin to heal not just the class
> divide but America itself. Liberty and civic harmony have been
> hijacked by partisanship. Our friendly disposition toward demagoguery
> and authoritarianism is allowing it to happen.
We shouldn't trust our immediate reaction but advocate for and see one
another clearly to make better choices.
I recently read a book by Mathew Fox where he infers that Donald Trump
and the MAGA movement are the Antichrist. he draws from the mystics
like Meister Eckhart to try to understand the significance of the anti
Christ which is very interesting. His inference to the contemporary
American context however is entirely based on the unexamined dominant
narrative endorsed by the rich and powerful. I was very disappointed
having a youthful hero of mine hypocritically slandering the MAGA
movement as intolerant bigoted self serving liars. In his uncritical
praise of Kamala Harris he ignores that the Democratic party canceled
its primaries to push Kamala and her unwavering support of war and the
deep state into power. The Democratic party was once a party that stood
for peace. Now we find that one time anti war contenders of the
Democratic party Tulsi Gabard and Robert Kennedy Junior are endorsing
Trump while GOP war criminals, Dick Cheney and George Bush are endorsing
Kamala. "by their fruits you shall know them"
At a MAGA event Organized by another one time democrat Bret Weinstein;
Russel Brandt, Jorden Peterson and Jimmy Dore make a theological appeal
for a populism of mutual respect and working class solidarity to put an
end to war.
Russell Brand @RussellBrand) with Dr. Jordan B. Peterson
(@JordanBPeterson) | Rescue the Republic
<https://youtu.be/Boj1yKaRoYg?si=m91_gP8zbPgbgAtH>
Jimmy Dore (@thejimmydoreshow | Rescue the Republic
<https://youtu.be/-4hBckhSG6A?si=hBWLN0VD5qiByKil>
This is that kind of healthy populism that is necessary in this age of
demagoguery.
Art
On 10/03/24 1:43 p.m., Patricia Smiley via Sundaycommunity wrote:
> *I have been receiving this newsletter in my mailbox for a few years.
> I don't remember how I came across it in the first place but
> apparently it is produced in my new hometown of Hamilton! (Remember
> the bishop of Hamilton in the 1980s. A very thoughtful and truly
> progressive man who was generally interested in young people and how
> they came to their faith. I met him on retreat at Guelph one time and
> had a nice conversation with him - I was definitely part of the youth
> category at the time being about 23 - and didn't realize he was the
> Bishop. He was genuinely interested in me and my plans for living out
> my faith.*
> *So, Hamilton was definitely at one time a place to inspire and foster
> faith.*
> *I was interested in this piece that is the forerunner this week, as
> it touches in a topic that was brought up in last Sunday's reflection
> time. Being interested in the interplay of civil society and the
> powers that be, this article has some thoughtful suggestions about how
> our young people enter civil society as those who can now vote and
> support those powers. It seems to me sometimes that the elders of the
> Church (the hierarchy) don't care about young people and how we would
> want them to be educated in making their path to social and
> environmental justice in the world they live in. You have to admit
> our generation has made a bit of a mess of the environment especially.*
> *So, I hope those who are interested in the progress of our next
> generations take some interest and this provokes some thought.*
> *
> *
> *Peace, Pat*
> *
> *
> /Patricia Smiley
> /
> /email: smileypatricia76 at gmail.com
> /
> /mobile: 647-517-1599
> /
> /
> /
>
>
> ---------- Forwarded message ---------
> From: *Comment* <editors at comment.org>
> Date: Thu, Oct 3, 2024 at 12:36 PM
> Subject: A politics of hope
> To: <smileypatricia76 at gmail.com>
>
>
> On populism. On citizenship. On Genesis.
> View in browser
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVRY5nR32W69t95C6lZ3nVW5wgbJc20cpzZW17Jtq58HpvK2W4j6Lkp4vCbzmW8xgb6l5zWZjjW7MRjvw265Rn4W7Qqg6R3__43YW9cZ2Qy3-t44NW6M80Pq1hCqCyW2s4mjt7rY5VTW44n1nz3pp_DNW8Vhbbd1-TQxqW454_CT4jWV55Vqc6jy6FFL83N34RWNzsLVncW6FkxzQ95TtpnW2kgWTM2VFT6mW3nzM3g27smFBVBDG_z1rYd42W8X6NjJ1vG1zHW11vQDf8X31_wW8xXnf_5byHwZW2qgfvQ6pHXtQW14rV5598F3vrW6LQk628RjGmmW2DJc-V81HPrMW7GXDF66qDGTXVyHDp83CT4kYW2BRZxN5kj777VtFKPm61TZLSW3FWVsw8l5ZNvW4mjd6n86Zv1dW1DrBR66WNrNrW4lYJB96X0XpZW138nd_3HGHhLW3vcncY7ZYxkhVnLk224ql2MFf6ysRv404>
>
>
> On populism. On citizenship. On Genesis.
>
> Comment
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVSd3qgyTW6N1vHY6lZ3lvW4p5DR-1dm7FKW3Wg4Pp1Fwg8WW82fCbd1xP02ZW1nrQh93_3zQgW28kN-x4sLSm5W2wdlDS8DJ0F-W8G2_-S1P16vcW7mQlmN1MRF9SW86cX0Q4Xk444N44-3tFzH91hW7w5g_F7rsQNmW60lTm14wlKt-W7GwBx11gchsPW4MQPnQ2wkd7kW9jjqK37Mc6shW5ZtPJM6Rt74zW3LDDLc8PJcMxW6xvCkJ1X7zmxW7FMt448lQ1Q6N7G51Ccn8d-JN2kvR_jJRv1GW5lcYny57G3c_f5kP0b404>
>
>
> comment-line-60
>
>
> The Possibilities and Perils of Populism
>
>
> A working-class perspective on the fragile American dream.
>
> Skyler Adleta, The Possibilities and Perils of Populism
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVT63qgyTW8wLKSR6lZ3npW6qy1T5960JdhW4RskF34j40nTW7k83HM6dcSscN1dhZ76Q_Tc0N3PVslNYTlm5W82WXTF1d2zDKW865Fgk3cbw4kW6_pyHp3y_8hvVrvk2772S0T1W8sLRm21pQrjJW6J4cDL2tXHZ6W16YRlg1zxLpgVS3d6c82BQJ7W4nvlvc5YhZ80W6KwFn18Q2f7vW35381F8_th_KW3MZQQy4xQ557W4GVjB16yKV7ZW5PjZ3F3pCz_BN7w-T61YTBRGW5d_K6z3n_vtFN6SWLTytTtmPN1k_L7PL-wpLW1YTMd-8wSrCsN7ph8rD98B0SW4Ydc0c3kH6TBW56WwFC8lB_2hW47DrBT8Wx7Bzf1T7Tmz04>
>
>
> It’s easy to get whipped up by populist rhetoric. We like the
> belonging it provides us, even when—especially when—it pushes others
> out. While some tribalism is unavoidable in a US culture where
> differences run deep, Skyler Adleta
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVT63qgyTW8wLKSR6lZ3mNW41-b2P16YtGqV4gsxH37NzNhW1GyX-98yLLH5W7SSN8F78DMH1W5pnk_n8gbd-2W4HN-9n3dwjmKW7LyfCf31gt1lW3kQl0v8RZXpYW7M58MV1vF3XbW8vnyPR2BCDgGW5DWQyD8Tdwq1N8fJBZxc4YX0W15SSdG851wbzW3xhp9b6NqyRlW5ZG_1N4nZsfGW2ZcnmY6yL5-vW4dPYz-2VzxN7N5WQgmJS4NY0W5w5mb38XPrx5W1hXd0n3LLm_-W2HfR1X1LGswlW5wZP2c2K1bckW1qWh418g33t4W1vQq2G65HmDxW7xGS5X4n6b9tF6bbGf2nF5sW9gvBH07RpF0sW68HWhD2S5_5Mf6Dp3jR04>
> also makes a compelling argument that “there is something distinctly
> un-American in how populism is manifesting itself in working-class
> society today.” What concerns Adleta is the “fear and anger” that are
> fanning the flames of populism to the point where followers on each
> side “are willing to relinquish their convictions into the hands of a
> political leader.” Such “leader worship” is not good for the polity.
>
> During Donald Trump’s first run for the White House, Adleta was
> working in a factory and catching snippets of /The Apprentice/ star
> talking angrily about immigrants flooding into the country and jobs
> being shipped overseas because the Democrats did not care for the
> working class. Adleta, a card-carrying member of that class, “took
> Donald Trump’s dire warnings as little more than those of a carnival
> ringmaster.” Yet over time, the narrative started to draw him in.
> Adleta started seeing himself and his people as the victims of
> decisions the Democratics had made. And while he found a home in many
> of Trump’s policies, his identification with Trump’s rhetoric came at
> a cost: “I invited in bitterness and dissatisfaction and bade farewell
> to the healthy patriotism and determination found in the classical
> American mythology of promise.”
>
> Then, Adleta found a hero in another American politician: Alexander
> Hamilton. Listening to the soundtrack to Lin-Manuel Miranda’s musical
> (and reading Ron Chernow’s biography on which it is based), Adleta saw
> the potency of a story about a hardworking outsider rising up through
> industry and perseverance. “I do think,” Adleta writes, as he reflects
> on his return to the factory where he eventually rose up, improved
> himself, and found his version of the American dream, “something
> verging on the sacred occurs when hope is allowed to leaven a people’s
> cultural identity in sobriety and solidarity.” (17 min read
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVT63qgyTW8wLKSR6lZ3n3W9drYGT8YQsgfW2C_t7C4P-ypWN2h-QgmR_8FlN2PLgygFqmVpW1-m2tJ6hxKMsW60KJ325_MnTgW1j-tDd2FtlH3N3y3nRd3-y72W6wbR8z75LzWWW8D63yK36txGYW4wFzrR1Dw5hrVrWdhs8jhCYHW3HdqCB4xm5zJW7p1wty3rysrgW65xDlx53293rN3QJlb5HNs2rW4-72zP3hD_SlN5Ddt_rJ8KdnN7f9Cn1Zktp4W2bD0Rs6GZwrYW6fv91d1NsYPdW6HrLx93cxwmKW3Jf_Ls77-38YW8H1GjY3ZqZvsW7nk5lh4VSB4JW5YdJs45yGWbVW74kl9G4Mc1X7W6zW2xx16sQB-f7_SC6n04>)
>
> *Read more*
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVT63qgyTW8wLKSR6lZ3p0W62NmVS2ByjgFW3j9Mx120Dz6QW2_95602ZBV5pW5wPlM929lsBwN8_xf6L6RWmlW1J72fV3FrSKgW7GF9Rc11GPJQW1Fj1z831qk_LW5s0xD71zf5f5W89MRqK4_zFlQW6BfLBK1Kk1WsW4mcdqk2_5s4BW25KpMX7mxdbrN96nHGChw8s-W3XpJhd55sbHxW7M9Vvy1PCqxVW7bR7Q_3hLRKmW5SC5wk1tH-xyW2_GKTh2sXP6_W55CZsY9lc4FnW13Qw3z8rfxmyN2KL59XZQWY3W4TJLVh23KgNwW7-z-yw4XLMDsW72lrlN3XVMFlW7v465C89vH4kW7WSb-W1ylp7QW33h7NJ37QKVZf8ln6Hj04>
>
>
>
> From the Archives: Citizens Aren’t Just Born. They’re Formed
>
>
> Why civil society is no substitute for a distinctively political
> education.
>
> Kevin de Dulk, Citizens Arent Just Born. They're Formed
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVT63qgyTW8wLKSR6lZ3kFVR_TKj849b1sVfx_4T3zf2M8W2b1sGy7stWgKW4q71Dm2GWN9dW7-rL-D3XJbtxW37wxT_2P35lDW1m24fh7CbvMPW6ZQ3nP2_w2T7VMZTgF599W68W5mF6c083YBkZW5-_j7Z1_CjDPW5qzqrp5c0WqgW2F1Z5Q5Qg2W1N5vknDPRDbqTW79F-wz4d5wD4N3hypDRGcFCSW599zPg29gK-vW22qTrm8nnGhMW2y1VXv6wWpZPW3vSs2-32qhHKW2Ywj8y6ynvBkW833Rzv6FyDbRVphhNB5jjqdHVqNhmd2xS0M3W1Kvn4R3mTn8MW57VyhC2cMqv3W6dc5xC7H_y8BW8H2KkY6K0tq6f877w_T04>
>
>
> When the university where political scientist Kevin den Dulk
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVT63qgyTW8wLKSR6lZ3pXW27bvyG4vvnb8W7qLZSZ2HRRsMW8sWVJl5D5qgTVxgWds5MsSJTW8mcQsJ4gx94BW6nCjMW5J25XHW7wDtgL3KMWjrW71x6wr164PXBVbXH-L179nP_W2XkXsW18ZKfVW60vFWp8d2Km-W9hZh7f3SVQPzN2-w82gVNsppW65_TYB8RNw4MW8TCbwG6n4KZhW5wnHxr8LQMpDW8_FLm63zH5ZgW6s2MnQ6KwcttW19KvG551qydfN42b30SSycxLW820qLS87XqLVW3SKVzX6nfy6qW61G4mj5bj00zW4S2G1z79lvq-W6P7qSX6FG1nlW19Lqlc5xYtTZW5VYRrW7cY422N395nWw_8pVLf6hTGNT04>
> was employed created its strategic vision, they named civic engagement
> as one of their goals for student education. But what exactly does
> that look like? And how is civic formation undertaken within the
> confines of academia? In this essay from the /Comment/ archives, den
> Dulk acknowledges that civil society plays a role in such formation,
> but by no means should it be the only one with stakes in the game:
>
> Let me stipulate that civil society, under the right conditions,
> /does/ help us cultivate our life in common. The evidence is deep and
> wide on that point, though qualified considerably by those conditions.
> We might come away from participation in fraternal groups and sports
> leagues and houses of worship with capacities and dispositions that
> good citizens should possess. But maybe not. And recent evidence
> suggests that “maybe not” describes the reality more often than some
> civil-society triumphalists see or admit. Civil society, it seems,
> will not save politics.
>
> My university is not alone in misplacing political formation. The
> problem is widespread, even in the Western democracies we might expect
> to pay closest attention to educating citizens. The problem is also
> urgent, as public institutions and political cultures across the globe
> crack under the pressures of new forces and movements. Our efforts at
> civic education are not up to the task of the political moment. The
> challenge is how to educate for citizenship when civil society is not
> necessarily built for that purpose—and might even, under the right
> conditions, choke the effort. The challenge is how to educate for
> citizenship by taking politics and its locus in the state seriously.
> (17 min read
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVT63qgyTW8wLKSR6lZ3nMW6Xdvyg6fByknVC3M8x6TpqdLW7fZsFb778GvbW5Vyts46n-z4mW1wVy9t4wP_p_W3_sxZN4WlMj-VnMTp_689qZTN1H4lY4jMs-zW1-1gyB60-vG-VLwsNT4YMGSBW3Dpnh11X45VcW3TH14S981vgyW332b8p2MwxppW6_fmw01w7-JzVj2Wnv8CBk52W7BMRVg12mFFnVsr20K249gm6W6N1zWd1m5B5hW4kQr91477hjyW1ZqMtd6wMhXpW9bj0vD7p7BZ-W37nbNq31zJ6CW6csFfF40dwdcW5GTT_891v6R5N6VT55VbHQ2lW66bFCc3l3mzNW7Nbc8n7P5WjPW7fW1dJ7kWnFHf65D0X204>)
>
> *Read more*
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVT63qgyTW8wLKSR6lZ3mRW3wfn_V5Fn45cW33YShH7Mc59RW1W-m7F7b9PYLV2bBRN1rtRTgW93Y17R61B9s9W6Xtcdx4cpFHSW1_l2jy4lXRz4W4l2Hmv4KF7vDW58_p7H1-wmvxW1pBm-p3L9XJWW92T5-d81Ft7yW3ptR6s6LnqG5N2Q3tJxsjhPVW5CyF4C95fNvBW24Hnv-6sdZsnW8cWJQv65cY0KW1nZKjC8JcLKRW3rwSyb6Q19yHW8DYK9c4fGCP6W2gc-5Y6GLlhlW67TPFv75_Bd_W6Lhb-f7R22DXW6fgCQH1H_C4nW19g4rr80Fl7LW8F2sS96b-lbMW1LsR6N1cLNX4W5M5pt63fDDVyW46cBVD2xNV4vf5ftXfq04>
>
>
>
> Podcasts
>
>
> The latest audio from /Comment./
>
> Conversing-social-ROUND
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVSx3qgyTW7lCdLW6lZ3m6Td7dV91YNYRN58lDrG_T0xRW1-xwFm33QbFMW50dlRs2X3V2XN1tsLtcM1PBkW71rf_x5z-hD-W84FLrL3MZHjKN9hW5kVv5XTlW4ff8zD7rKcZLV1xVqM94Jx6JW7GVLyF2xw1hYN28CbJcWtzNVW6yfr7-499QkkW9fpzQb5rsq0dW5rKYPH3Vqn3WW4py8Qy3SdDw0N810R5KKMBBFW6dWJHH97BmVsW2b-9596ZV-ZMVVRK0Q1JwSXBW36BGsN3YGnp4W8S9Vdq3t2z6MW2QfB7t5f4YxwW5QpDWD6bPsp9f7fY7KC04>
>
>
> CONVERSING
>
> Reading Genesis
>
>
> A conversation with Marilynne Robinson.
>
> OCTOBER 1 | 46 MIN
>
> *Listen*
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVSR3qgyTW7Y8-PT6lZ3m-W740kCD4jkdjkW6FjlXc4TbYChVlg5Z65b725SW1RvnHV3vm6BMW6G3Dhl6Sz9JcW4V_MP36CCVvHW2FkZG853LHlkW7sxfTQ31kdyRW5QJ0d03-bvdzW1L2tsM2FkgMKW41-s8S7TjYvwW5-RBsn7_dtdVW3R83Jq41PGZYW7s_rRN4k9llfW71wqnr76T1kSVG_4R94MCS4bW3lvYLf8s__jkW5T8gQ42XwTVbW2L3SX334LrNYW7PsNTd5shlmBW3tqRdZ3qysthW5crvd28-2fg8W4NQq2K5lHRhyW7hv4dt1dmvR6W23lnrw8n-ScxVglrVr8JPb8cf5D8y4H04>
>
>
>
> What we’re reading
>
>
> From the /Comment/ editorial team.
>
> Image
>
>
> /Image/
>
> Congratulations and best wishes to Molly McCully Brown, the new
> editor-in-chief of /Image/ journal. Read her first, beautifully
> written editorial, “Nebraskan Mystery
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVSR3qgyTW7Y8-PT6lZ3lqW6yylRR8sjzZVVk6CWH4q1ty2W8YdpK954PPpPN6BTWwtWp7nBW92_7SZ8s-qTGN8DQZfmKrpBwW2DrhRJ8HXs2CW5MnWXR6FDQ7lW2NQW2927h6mpW8LsVy_8XlxPJW16FKxw3_pJQZN1zwB-FV7lM-W4v6TCv5_tywWW21-0Pg7TCV_ZW7Fb6PH4MV6pXVvMFyB5jy7_QW9jK8pK4Q8LQcW4Ky4yN3jSvl0W1n2ndd7WddtCW2Kcn6P65dp9TW5CFQ-B7tyf8pW1XDLw_42gl_8MNYcVsgvY20W4HqwJ9344ZVKW7R5dcf389F_3VwB4f46_kwDxf3bs-v-04>.”
>
>
> The-Atlantic
>
>
> /The Atlantic/
>
> Elite colleges are realizing that their students can’t read books
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVRF5nR32W5BWr2F6lZ3mJW7-lNgy7C4RM4W4lJrm82ykF_lN3c0JQfB8jZlW5cx2Bm7m8JpWW8_SN047HkQp1W6KNYpC8FVNgkW7-S83W1KHwpLW3c17WV1KYz2MW369d3W2V53tsVW_PBT3cYsZcW50kJ208WJv4XW6jMqpT3tch9RW7y3x0v3BM041W2C_6p827w_QgVR5qGj3P5Xy7W51LmFX78Qy1XW14yrCh8GWt7wW5yjzh85z66-xW3fRzDm95gTBjVHdN_N1Vm9fGW1DtLCT4jkybxW7N3nh_7l8FQMVB4B5w2mlwRMW71Zm3x3H_RhCN28bXnLV33MtW7RYrHb7vwz9TVv6ZBp58kYkKW79F6Ry5kBN88W1VgN_c7_mpTMW41KG8L5swxPmN7rql6xVZwvjW4Pk4D47YLjW0W6hLM0H3Nd9Z0W6RL04K6Ky5_Kf84KRl-04>—a
> problem that stems from the reduced expectations of primary and
> secondary schools.
>
>
> Economist
>
>
> /The Economist/
>
> The vice presidential debate is considered an almost non-factor in
> election cycles, but did J.D. Vance and Tim Walz show another way to
> debate
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVRl5nR32W50kH_H6lZ3pPN41xfyS97d_pW36SpZQ6z_KNvW19ltwq6lV192V63_DP7bV3w0W2jlFV-4Pw76dW7py_MZ8Kjlw2VwRl9J2sTYZ_W3JT4Vh2DbYtSW6c8yVx8s0LWKW4Z4CCQ2g-5hYW4S7NGW1QcGDkW4DS45K5cYVY1W8bHzHr95pkYKW2Z12jb4N1VckW8B3d636qs55ZW6D-M2144VBzlN5Z6xdY85h9lW3yf-x722qFDbW6kKxlV7BVhbqW3x4JYF1bH_tkW7WtbKc6s0SpBW2L40f67f3MT2W4lNHg_2Gjk0zW6d5C3748yq6CW4Wnlhf5LBj8mW3zb-Tn8BCpP_W7tSlqM7BL8WXV7THDw7KfvthW3csRmJ4VVjCyW91PW165Y5HK7W3Ktzvx2wk_4-W4bLh8c74jnrYf7xcJQl04>?
>
> LARGE MONOGRAM - CREAM-1
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVSd3qgyTW6N1vHY6lZ3nLW7sT9p_1_FvcCW5dTFjB1jnykGV70c0K32LJHmW11zQmx9lmB_nW7s3_pD5xwdfkW8zwx-N7QbhZjW5fKtdh2HVlswW8x86362ZfsCHW1p3Qsy7LZ4nnW112vbq26NpvxVyFzTB4lBvmHW9fhZJD2SmYPqW5RT5TC8Z0w_XW288kkW7GNrzJW2yNW1g8bydyXW9gXYQ77G4JhSW2vqb5d4P3pnSW1NDsh35pynTZW37nNMz2-cKqfW790hG11CD2NSW45kfFg3B24lJW6d0PPl4Z3rJWf1fhtM-04>
>
>
>
> Public theology for the common good.
>
>
> Was this email forwarded to you? We invite you to subscribe to
> /Comment Weekly/ and join readers who receive fresh,
> thought-provoking articles once a week in their inbox.
>
> *Subscribe*
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVSx3qgyTW7lCdLW6lZ3mjW2LDH1p8gxlyzW8LwNpQ8j-_3tW7yVJhw1TGWbkW2nrXXL7rKr0jW5bx_DJ38C7m1W1jyvKX1Qx6vMW5lJzxx8ycWx7N1clXpw30nv1W2h2shh8_9F_9W7Yc1wP7s5MHtN2yY79g2bl9mW15K1jf12rp7VW8jqZS78_PRTxW97l6lY1TGY6dVk3Ljv2t4_T-W4VlnYY6K3JGqW8yZ4885ntQpjVDVr8x3sJHRzW3qHKS-3dJ5hvW4PQwP23MBMdqW2hK4Hh3xy9NkW2x5drP1nfcPhW4GPByN6qGJTBW5gj6vD2G9H5Xf4_s-pY04>
>
>
> Cardus, 1 Balfour Drive, Hamilton, ON L9C 7A5, CA
>
> Unsubscribe
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVT6fjG-jW8wNQc-6lZ3kGW1LPHz46mS1JcW8f_y2y97Bbj7N44bdKH_MTGVN3PcX94gksXLW6BGR0x5_PyFqW8g05X696b-TXW85wbm412Sp1gW2JD3Pb7jwVTlN7B9Lr873g21N3_lXLxGRdJjW8_D1MH6cDV8PW5t3l772b_XvDVrSH9T92c8llW8kpQ6H5_6fY7W6Fs9VX2RGFRPW6StnzQ4xCBDwW6kTj4H6dsbBfW7vlDMd2Y-D0yW4zNydn5g3M14W9kHvgj4KyVqnW341k1N7bSVT-W6kRNfy5y0gC7W7DqB1t80TFyPW2X7Ngv59NJl-W8D72zn7FgkwQW5z-PXn24lc5mW70G2st3C0z2PW2j3ZxW2ghqy1W6H_6Gg8Lr9YfW7jRCDx665g1-VfF-cy4ln7QDW2zXnn748sXVLN24v74_1qn8vV_tGPJ7_vLp6W8GKhlJ5BJvpTW2Vcngm7Dhm2MW4QmP7H3CH-s9W8hphzt7JHrRNW1t0cMp50yRHXW6Vg5Mz21XT7nN6pNxwk89VNSW5t7_6231Sw2MW5r435Z2_yVTyW5C4Xj76PBKdqW8gqGFD2PSdjvW55FhK335y53HW5Snx1855fzf3W43VjHX70FhgLW45wBH61DB_jhW2_D3_J6WgYSTN2vWJP7cS9YLW7hd5_0879MCpW7zVfk81tJhR2W7xBZ3b2nzSCKW8MLTdt5ZXfB4W1k11TX82b03BW24Fxpj67LTB_W8MmbjL43kXTyW6G357x6q2JmvW4F3kYW70-0GcN4KPVy3-KFj5W1J6whl1Cm80BW31XJLk3mB41cW7RVZzM4pSRY2W5bxtHd1PyBsnW98gHTn8p8CZCW22Vd3_3YV-GwW8yfJdC3Zc_8wW8wNRW24cKvbFW8hHjln5GMkbQVksXwY5GnbJLW7VGGYY4Lq6XHW5GnxDR5r0vgKN5DLcS_pCBC_VP-7YF5L2shLN66LMLhNKRsmVXrnV81817BDW16Fj4l7DB_fbW6CxNX88cYgDrW8H04hz97DQcNW6dpGtK1v0ry0N4Zgtp0-dhF8W78Z_-Y8yKSjKW1J9qnz351KMxW2bL-4K3vxpwgW6wFg9L6QpknyVKzkld1pv1bQW7QrdvN2r6B9FW91NzwK1fGq5KW5L_XF56HsNw1W8Vqln62p59yfW5S0hnK13857rW7bxwgk11tq3SW5SWcdr1X80qzW891tpL4fSZ4gN4_b6SmRYgtPW5Y2f7d37TXLfW93drv724f8gcW3sb6Cj1Sz-PfW2WShjg4DtnlXW4xbLDp8nNp4nW57T0bH3PNKMPW2W38kv85XHYCW5T52mW3-QnXTW6KMWq26806D6W1LV3Wl7g0mkPN6jj3V89wvFTVtbRrQ4DVNlmf696chP04>
> Manage preferences
> <https://open.comment.org/e3t/Ctc/OS+113/d2CL7D04/VVtT9p3rJxLlVCW-Zc4yZmh8W67tPB75lKqcvMmLVSRfjG-jW7Yc3906lZ3mJW3Lcfw8913qYlW96kXkb2fybLjW4D4HBB8GtqWyW2wsmcV7GgyHmW4vf0vb1d6RCjW8ysXdM6BnNt0MPHVsNMJ6CjVB4fxQ62PVxdVPRN6y3Xwcr_W4-MwFL1xlVrwW1g6NmL55xn77W7sjQ2m1cHrllN9hCq8vdgB4-VqwzrR3fK2WsW773D6984Z4fHW1h7htM7dhz13W1N4yTf57YVWxN3Ln7mHd26myW2jmtJB3T2k6MW2HlpdJ2ZKSqTW40QknC1Jq7CXW3qVvk42hCN41W420C3646nCX3W1b058B7t81kcW1Tk1PG1lNgXKW6snWjb8yMNVjW2TKvbK4svJB6W1djNlS1KBnwqW2WV_-Z3RRT9XW8JCXfM3zXh2jW8Ds7PV4Hx2vDW7TPmhp6lpx4mN8wFSp24Nx7rN3dq6FLfrQf8V1NvrM4zFNqQW8CFDNg4wW7fFW1vQqt62lx6cTW5dN21P2P-T7yW6K3JbJ3GwlqQW5lyxk33PlDx3W8KwT915rjcXQW7ky_qB6f0FzKN30rfCWtpJ30W6yrftZ40cFsKVYphCP4BnWWWW8s_CvX1sCTxTW6ZgW5j5mbd5rW8dNYkp8VMb8zW13YSHm6TwpMZW8lDSBL5FHh2TN4_nM_fqm21zW1XFw-31Fj5XKW7FMZKM8HDNVFW6sX_cG4rywpPW5frQtg7Jz6prW3ZFZRQ3clQMWVfzJ081w4Kx9N2C7WMZL-tgzW6h1-mQ5k3PXnW6mNMMp8j8B2LW32s44T6CLVbBW1jpNQK17Wht6W33hWN54ydZHmW6PgL6C4lvjWjW8StC_43Yj3KTW2mXy-d90P92QW6KCb8l2n0JpWW2BRgcn7Chmj0W7f9WRV5q-0dfW8SX94t7-vHJsW2GllxF2ZwcBPW78n-8l7XJhvFW2GwZQw5CDT8TW2Fvn_07JMFQQW4-8QBW7s9WMJN341FrBWN_LhW40jQw547GkNxW5Gq_s66TF26TW7j-wYt5XTV6_W711JhN74RJZZV_RDd364xfCHW3SmMq98kVV-fW5CbD9v1kgHZDV-wsks8M4p6mW3cNdWg2j_wVLW80mMKt5ZF7wPVB2ShZ43RFjYW5tLFpy7jkx5NN5FC1Gy-9St7W5n0k-D9h0RGFVfGLyW3lDlksW8b0q9H4NVN5mW44Xsl54YBWDvN8Y7m2qq3GHMW5P9ywf1ZKgp9VCcw6V434lFxVDw_FD72CfpDW4q3_PS8l0pFHN3Tk19xP-ySsW3j5yGb4vylYvVv2vSV8r8BQBW1nJmCj1lrdQ2W10MXtC1CYZVwW1PPgwY5LqFm3W971B7M7MDPP3W3HkNt56wCvDMf4FlR2n04>
>
>
>
> ________________________________________
>
> Sundaycommunity mailing list
> To send message:sundaycommunity at integralshift.ca
> To manage Subscription:https://sundaycommunity.integralshift.ca
> To Unsubscribe send email to:sundaycommunity-unsubscribe at integralshift.ca
> To Subscribe send email to:sundaycommunity-subscribe at integralshift.ca
>
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.integralshift.ca/pipermail/sundaycommunity-integralshift.ca/attachments/20241003/3e894a14/attachment.htm>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: photo_2024-09-19_08-05-47.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 97867 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://lists.integralshift.ca/pipermail/sundaycommunity-integralshift.ca/attachments/20241003/3e894a14/attachment.jpg>
More information about the Sundaycommunity
mailing list